McShay: Cardinals’ best pick is cornerback Harlan Miller

May 2, 2016, 3:09 PM | Updated: 8:31 pm
Southeastern Louisiana defensive back Harlan Miller runs a drill at the NFL football scouting combi...
Southeastern Louisiana defensive back Harlan Miller runs a drill at the NFL football scouting combine, Monday, Feb. 29, 2016, in Indianapolis. (AP Photo/L.G. Patterson)
(AP Photo/L.G. Patterson)

The Arizona Cardinals’ selection of Robert Nkemdiche seemed like a win-win for both the team and the player.

Nkemdiche landed on a team where draft prospects with off-field issues have thrived, and the Cardinals history of finding value in these players is noteworthy.

Those facts make Nkemdiche seem like a no-brainer for Arizona’s best pick in the draft, but ESPN’s Todd McShay disagrees.

I thought about putting Robert Nkemdiche here. I get why they took him in the first round, and as an organization, they’ve been good at handling players with baggage. But one thing that scares me off: Chandler Jones has had issues with synthetic marijuana, and now he’ll be in the same meeting room with Nkemdiche, who has had his own off-field problems.

Instead, McShay went with sixth-round selection Harlan Miller.

So I went with Miller, on whom we had a fourth-round grade — the Cardinals got him in the sixth. His combine performance scared off a lot of teams (4.65-second 40; 4.43 short shuttle), but some guys are better players than testers. With Tyrann Mathieu coming off injury and some other unanswered questions in the secondary, Miller is capable of making the roster and contributing, which is great for a sixth-rounder.

Miller will look to find ways of contributing as a hybrid defensive player, similar to the way Mathieu and Deone Bucannon did in their early years with the team.

Scouts Inc.’s Steve Muench listed the pros and cons of Miller as a football player.

A small-school prospect who stood out at the Senior Bowl, Miller has the ball skills and instincts to develop into a playmaker. He also shows good balance and body control transitioning in and of breaks on tape, but he didn’t test well at the scouting combine. There are concerns about his ability to make the jump from FCS SE Louisiana to the NFL, even though he played well in Mobile, Alabama. There’s also room for improvement when it comes to Miller’s ability to defend the run.

The Cardinals have had recent success in the sixth round.

2013 sixth-rounder Andre Ellington has made a major impact in Arizona’s backfield since being drafted and 2012 sixth-rounder Justin Bethel has made the Pro Bowl as a special teams player. Bethel is also expected to compete for the starting cornerback spot opposite of Patrick Peterson.

Life Changer Loans

Arizona Cardinals

The Cincinnati Bengals announced Tuesday, Aug. 9, 2022, that Paul Brown Stadium will be called Payc...
Associated Press

Cardinals visit Bengals on Friday at renamed Paycor Stadium

The home of the Cincinnati Bengals will no longer carry the name of team founder and NFL pioneer Paul Brown.
11 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals' Marco Wilson runs drills during the NFL football team's training camp at State F...
Arizona Sports

Marco Wilson knows he’s earned nothing in Cardinals’ CB rotation

Arizona Cardinals second-year pro Marco Wilson is aware that relative success his rookie year hasn't cemented his place as the No. 2 corner.
11 hours ago
Arizona Cardinals CB Antonio Hamilton runs during training camp on Monday, Aug. 8, 2022, in Glendal...
Tyler Drake

Cardinals notebook: Antonio Hamilton continues to gain his peers’ respect

It's still relatively early on in camp, but one name that's been talked about more and more with every Cardinals practice is Antonio Hamilton.
1 day ago
Arizona Cardinals tight end Maxx Williams (87) avoids the tackle of Philadelphia Eagles strong safe...
Tyler Drake

Cardinals’ Maxx Williams taking ‘day-by-day’ approach in return from injury

Arizona Cardinals TE Maxx Williams surprised many this offseason when he was taken off the physically unable to perform list last Thursday.
1 day ago
Follow @AZSports...
Character Counts

Kyler Murray gives young fan signed jersey after boy had one stolen

Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray and his teammates showed the impact of a small but thoughtful gesture on Monday.
1 day ago
D.J. Humphries #74 of the Arizona Cardinals on the field during pregame warm-ups before the game ag...
Sam Graveline

Cardinals’ D.J. Humphries takes last spot in PFF’s 2022 top OT rankings

Fresh off an extension with the Cardinals, LT D.J. Humphries took the last spot in Pro Football Focus' top offensive tackle rankings.
2 days ago
McShay: Cardinals’ best pick is cornerback Harlan Miller